Saturday, October 3, 2009

Thursday, October 1, 2009

You are like the Buzzing of Flies to Him!

I'm sitting in my Public International Law class right now. It is my third attempt to take a worthwhile class on international law and, after a month, seems poised to be almost as much a failure as the previous two.

My regular professor, Ikechi Mgbeoji, is away this week. The LL.M candidate lecturing in his place is a female version of Dr. Janosz Poha from Ghostbusters II.


It's fortunate that the lecture has a corresponding Power Point slideshow, because I have no idea what Janosz is talking about; probably how Vigo (the scourge of Carpathia and the sorrow of Moldavia) flaunted international custom. The girl sitting in front of me evidently can't follow along either, because she's copying pictures from fashion blogs and uploading them to her Tumblr for some reason.

O, girl who sits in front of me, you are perversely captivating: you look like a disaster, with your hair bleached too many times, until it has the texture of a horse's mane (or at least appears to--I'm not stroking it); with your grunge-y clothes and sloppy giant purse; with your indifference toward your lectures and your surroundings1, manifested in frequent tardiness and a perpetual hunch; and yet--cumulatively these affectations compose a picture of wealth. How can this be? And how do I find your Tumblr?

But I didn't come here to ruminate on the elegance of my classmates; I came to learn about International Law, and as usual that seems less likely to occur with each passing moment.

Now I must gird myself to make a conspicuous departure.

1 can't argue with you there

Tuesday, September 29, 2009

Things Upon Which I Will Waste My Future Money

In roughly ten months, barring disaster, I will embark upon a year of articling, and begin making real money for the first time. Not as much as people that stopped going to school several years ago, of course, but nonetheless a huge step up from the tube-slide watching and shoe polishing of my past.

As that glorious time slowly approaches, I frequently find myself thinking about my first paychecks. Food and shelter will theoretically occupy a privileged position in my hierarchy of needs, but they are unexciting. Here's where the rest of the money will go, Maslow be damned:
  • Playstation 3 -- 'cause I may now finally be old and responsible enough to have my very own game platform without sacrificing my future, despite all evidence to the contrary
  • a vehicle that doesn't bounce around like a dune-buggy on even the flattest of surfaces -- probably one of these, one of these, or one of these
  • a TV so big it'll make my eyes bleed -- 'cause what's the point of the Playstation 3 if I have nothing with which to match its majesty?
  • this sweet shotgun, or one like it
  • suits -- whatever GQ tells me, for the first little while at least
  • new skates -- I have a sneaking suspicion that if I had just had some decent skates, instead of constant used ones, I could right now be retired from the NHL after blowing out my knee as a rookie
  • new ski boots -- same principle, but retired from winning Olympic gold medals instead of Stanley Cups
  • Batcave -- 'cause (1) I'll need a place to unwind after a long day on my feet chasing ambulances, (2) an arctic Fortress of Solitude is totally impractical and cold, (3) my suits will require a lot of space, and (4) the Batmobiles go in it
  • another external harddrive -- I'm running out of space, is all
  • Europe -- too many people are going there and enjoying it, shut it down; Asia too
  • taxes! -- decades of Liberal governments have created a monstrous welfare state that needs constant feeding (vote Conservative so we can kill it and buy more fun things with the money we'll save!)

Friday, August 28, 2009

Wednesday, August 12, 2009

Warning: Actual Legal Content


Don't worry, it's brief. Also, every use of the word 'brief' doesn't have to be a pun. How can you have an offence of "attempt to possess [narcotic] for the purpose of trafficking"?

Such a charge, on its face, seems either
(a) an attempt to charge someone with trafficking who ought to be charged with possession, because trafficking is indictable and the sentences are more severe; or
(b) redundant with a charge of Possession for the Purpose.

A circumstance has arisen, however, where it makes some sense: an individual (let's call him Smartest Cop Ever) comes into possession of a quantity of controlled substance (A Veritable Blizzard) and conceals it. S.C.E. has no apparent connection to the drug trade and no means of marketing or profiting from this windfall -- the Breaking Bad problem. As such, he has none of the common indicia of drug trafficking: scales, gobs of cash, debt lists, association with hip-hop stars. However, the sheer quantity of product, its location when eventually discovered, and S.C.E.'s behaviour make it unlikely that he kept the drugs for his own personal use.

UPDATE | There was a crucial fact missing from this sequence of events that distinguishes possession for the purpose of trafficking from attempted possession for the purpose: the police had substituted a decoy for the cocaine and as such the accused never possessed it in an amount sufficient to justify an inference of intent to traffic. Unbeknownst to him, the accused was in possession of a small amount of cocaine, and a large amount of flour with a tracking device buried inside.
*He's also charged with breach of trust by public officer, Criminal Code s. 122.

Monday, August 3, 2009

Jarndyce v. Jarndyce*

"The Lawyers have twisted it into such a state of bedevilment that the original merits of the case have long disappeared from the face of the earth. It's about a Will, and the trusts under a Will -- or it was, once. It's about nothing but Costs, now. We are always appearing, and disappearing, and swearing, and interrogating, and filing, and cross-filing, and arguing, and sealing, and motioning, and referring, and reporting, and revolving about the Lord Chancellor and all his satellites, and equitably waltzing ourselves off to dusty death, about Costs. That's the great question. All the rest, by some extraordinary means, has melted away.

... "All through the deplorable cause, everything that everybody in it, except one man, knows already, is referred to that only one man who don't know it, to find out -- all through the deplorable cause, everybody must have copies, over and over again, of everything that has accumulated about it in the way of cartloads of papers (or must pay for them without having them, which is the usual course, for nobody wants them); and must go down the middle and up again, through such an infernal country-dance of costs and feeds of nonsense and corruption, as was never dreamed of in the wildest visions of a Witch's Sabbath. Equity sends questions to Law, Law sends questions back to Equity; Law finds it can't do this, Equity finds it can't do that; neither can so much as say it can't do anything, without this solicitor instructing and this counsel appearing for A, and that solicitor instructing and that counsel appearing for B; and so on through the whole alphabet, like the history of the Apple Pie.

... "Counsel will have something to say about it; the Chancellor will have something to say about it; the Satellites will have something to say about it; they will all have to be handsomely fee'd, all round, about it; the whole thing will be vastly ceremonious, wordy, unsatisfactory, and expensive, and I call it, in general, Wiglomeration. How mankind ever came to be afflicted with Wiglomeration, or for whose sins these young people ever fell into a pit of it, I don't know; so it is."

* Charles Dickens, Bleak House (1851), at 118-122

Wednesday, July 22, 2009

Six months on

and the sheep are already wandering away.

And no wonder -- how dare Barack Obama not fix decades of decadence and graft after six months in office! At a time when the 24-hour news cycle is now 24 minutes long, who is he to think that people won't demand results in a similar time frame?

I think that the new president of the USA Bargainville should take to heart the story, probably apocryphal, of Soviet General Secretary Nikita Khrushchev's two letters to his successor Leonid Brezhnev (the one with the eyebrows). [EDIT: It is altogether likely that I stole this story from the Steven Soderbergh movie Traffic unconsciously.] A very cursory Google search did not yield this story so I will relate it as I recall it:
On the first day of Secretary Brezhnev's term in office, he sits down at his desk (steel, two hundred pounds, gunmetal blue, in the Bolshevik fashion) and opens the drawers. Inside the bottom drawer are two envelopes addressed to him from his predecessor. The first reads, "Open me the first time you get into trouble."

This being the Soviet Union, in due course Secretary Brezhnev is in political hot water. The Party is at his throat, the mob is at his doorstep. He opens the first letter. It contains only two words: "Blame me."

Secretary Brezhnev complies. He tells the Party that Khrushchev's legendary incompetence brought them to this pass, but that he will get them out of it. The Party blames Khrushchev, the mob is mollified.

Years pass and the Secretary's fortunes wax and wane. [Brezhnev was in power for eighteen years, until his death; this part of the fable is a little thin.] Finally, rampant economic stagnation cannot be ignored [at least that part is true] and the proletariat is whispering again. Despairing, Brezhnev rips open the second envelope. This one contains three words: "Write two letters."

Comrades Obama and Brezhnev both attained to the captain's chair, as it were, too late to turn their respective ships around, but just in time to take the blame for the vessels' going down. The difference between the two is that here we have some indication that Brezhnev's predecessor could spell.

Friday, July 17, 2009

A Proposed Moratorium

When a seventeen-year-old does something idiotic that mimics something (likewise idiotic) he saw in a movie, such as bombing a Starbucks like "Project Mayhem" did in Fight Club to dubious effect, the media shouldn't be allowed to say he was "inspired" to do the deed by said movie. "Inspiration" is what happens to inventors, artists, innovators. "Wildly missing the point of Fight Club" is what happened to this dude.

Anyway, if the poor, stupid bro really wanted to pay homage, or whatever, to "Project Mayhem" and Fight Club, he should have bombed a large piece of "corporate art" in a manner calculated to incidentally destroy a Starbucks. And then he should have gotten shot in the back of the head.

(I want to weep like Cornelius every time I have to type "Starbucks" without an apostrophe.)His name is Robert Paulson. His name is Robert Paulson. His name ...

Wednesday, July 8, 2009

Attn: skids

It is imprudent to report your victimization to police while you are high on crack cocaine.

The more you know! [chimes]

Tuesday, July 7, 2009

Skills that did not make it onto my articling applications

  • Gmail labels
  • tying a tie so that it falls to the proper length, just grazing the belt
  • alphabetizing bookshelves
  • furrowing brow in direction of caselaw/charge sheets/dockets/computer screens/justices of the peace
  • pluralizing multi-clause titles
  • avoiding street corner charities
  • unlimited girl pushups
  • hair volume

Friday, July 3, 2009

Fun with Quicklaw: Glaringly Self-Serving Edition

As summer edges damply forward, and back-to-school commercials linger threateningly just over the horizon, the thoughts of the aspiring lawyer turn idly to employment, and the grim spectre, casually-mentioned, that one's blog may be perused by decision-makers.

What was the last entry I made on this blog? the student wonders. Could it have been the one about the marijuana? Oh dear. That is not fairly representative. If only it could have been the one about justice (Texas-style), or that other one about how the Nashville Predators organization should give me $200. Oh well. Perhaps I am due for a new entry.

But what search string is called for in such a situation? Perhaps the interests found on one's resume will serve. The word 'caribou' in the British Columbia and Yukon law reports brings roughly 200 cases to attention. The noble beast has had some significant legal troubles, it would seem. A search for 'murder' within those results procures a rather more manageable six, among them them R. v. Wise, [1992] 1 S.C.R. 527. Odd, thinks the aspiring lawyer, I've come across this case before. Perhaps the volume of Canadian jurisprudence has been exaggerated!

The case should be known to any student with the unenviable task of arguing for the admissibility of ill-gotten evidence, under s. 24(2) of the Charter. Whether inclusion of such evidence will "bring the administration of justice into disrepute" is a question haunting many a moot court, and the Collins test haunts the dreams of many a moot court participant. Indeed, were the Supreme Moot Court of Windsor to have its way, young Jagrup Singh would today be walking free, despite the aspiring lawyer's best efforts in the spring of 2008, it must be admitted.

Mr. Wise, a suspect in a murder with possible serial implications, made the mistake of committing some mischief to property over $1000. Significantly over. Having placed an electronic tracking device in Mr. Wise's car during the course of their investigation, police had little trouble tying him to the destruction of a two-million dollar communications tower. The twisted hunks of metal found in his car provided fairly clearcut evidence.
Unfortunately, the police, armed with a warrant to search the man's property and vehicle, failed to install their tracking device until 30 hours after the expiry of that warrant. A Charter violation was made out, and Mr. Wise was acquitted. The Crown, however, was not so easily dissuaded. The Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court of Canada agreed that Mr. Wise should be imprisoned, in the interests of justice. While the accused's Charter rights under s. 8 were violated, the violation was forgivable based on the factors outlined in Collins. Noted Justice Cory for the majority of the Supreme Court, "the beeper monitoring of the accused's vehicle invaded a reasonable expectation of privacy" (para. 19) and thus violated s. 8 of the Charter; however, the evidence was not conscriptive, there was a pressing need for it, and the administration of justice was not brought into disrepute by its admission.

But what does the caribou have to do with it?

According to Justice Cory at paragraph 28, the mighty caribou herds solve a thorny problem afflicting law students nationwide: the definition of the word 'conscriptive' in s. 24(2) --
In this case, I agree with the court of appeal that the movements of the car constituted real evidence. There was no police compulsion or enticement which required the appellant to enter or drive his car. Rather he exercised his own free will. It was the accused who determined that he would drive his car, the routes he would follow and the manner in which he drove. The movement of an object may be transitory but it is real. The movement of a terrestrial body can be and often is plotted. That movement is transitory but real. The migratory route of the caribou herds is transitory but it is vital and real to those who depend upon that movement for food and clothing. So too is the movement of a motor vehicle real. This evidence could be considered conscriptive if the actions of the police forced or perhaps enticed the accused to utilize his vehicle and to follow prefixed routes in arriving at destinations selected by them.

Lessons learned:
  • If one happens to be a person-of-interest in an investigation into a rash of serial killings, it is best to keep one's head down, refraining from wanton destruction, even in the wilds.
  • The Collins test will stay with you long after the moot court's venerable doors have slammed on you. Whether or not evidence may be considered 'conscriptive' is a question which cannot safely be left to the academics. Only by the the migratory route of the caribou herds may you be saved.
Lessons learned in first year law, about which one is now uncomfortably reminded:
  • When the judge agrees to disagree with you about the meaning of the word upon which hinges the case, victory is probably not at hand.

Tuesday, June 30, 2009

The Month That Was June 2009

For the past two months, there have been three obstacles to regular or even sporadic updating of this site:
  1. having actual work to do,
  2. my inability to finish David Copperfield, and
  3. the DOJ's heroic vigilance over errant web-surfing (no Blogger, Facebook, Gmail, Twitter or Wordpress -- how will I know about new dead celebrity montages!), which relates to Obstacle 1 but merits its own bullet because I have so little willpower or self-control.
But it wouldn't do to let the month of June 2009 slip by without a single update, and so let us reflect upon

The Month that Was
  • June 1 - (present): stricken with either the most nagging cold ever or allergies for the first time in my life; hate and fear dogs, dust, grass, human touch, sunshine
  • June 4: police cadet calls me a "bleeding heart liberal"
  • June 8: security staff at Elgin Middlesex Detention Centre (read: screws) make uncharitable remarks and use foul language while audible over the Video Remand system; they are reprimanded by the Justice of the Peace
  • June 9: I review a file in which a prisoner tells the guards he has taken two ecstasy pills and has to go to the hospital, and then surrenders a bag of ten more ecstasy pills; this prisoner's date of birth is recorded as December 1996; I reflect on what I was doing when I was twelve years old and conclude that, though I wasn't dealing ecstasy, I might have been playing too much Warcraft II
  • June 12: accused person resolves the charges against him just short of his fiftieth appearance in #12 Court, at which date I really intended to ask whether or not we could, you know, get the show on the road a little bit
  • June 15: in Toronto for articling Q&A at the Ministry of the Attorney General (aka the provincial Crown's office); the two-hour production might have been reduced to one question ("do I have a hope of getting a job here?") and one answer (a snort)
  • June 17: back to Toronto for DOJ open house; a Crown prosecutor acquainted with my employer in London requests that I "ask him if he's sober these days"; I laugh because we're in public but do not pass on this greeting
  • June 19: I am required to encourage counsel to schedule pleas for Wednesdays only, when a federal Crown is guaranteed to be available to read in the charges; this request doesn't sit well with counsel, who don't want their clients to have to spend five more nights in jail in order that the federal Crown isn't inconvenienced; I resolve never to make such a request again
  • June 21: celebrate Father's Day by renting an enormous woodchipper for the whole weekend
  • June 21 (evening): want to watch Fargo for some reason
  • June 22: every member of London's news media turns out to #12 to see the two-minute appearance of a woman accused of murdering her three infant children; I try to sit up straight and look halfway competent for a change
  • June 23: the sole remaining person in the RCMP office remarks on his way out the door, "you're really burning the midnight oil these days" -- at 4:30 PM
  • June 25: Farrah Fawcett, biggest also-ran since Dodi al Fayed
  • June 26, 9:00 AM: a co-worker tells me that she thinks Michael Jackson was unfairly convicted by the media and holds out faith in his innocence -- which is ridiculous of course, but refreshing coming as it does from a prosecutor
  • June 26, 5:00 PM: board Greyhound bus en route to Toronto for the weekend; last remaining seat is next to a woman wearing a Snuggie; send text message to this effect to several people, careful to conceal the substance of the message from her view
  • June 28: miss Pride Parade in Toronto in favour of seeing Woody Allen's Whatever Works; conclude that God is LGBT; Whatever Works is an abomination and offends His sight
  • June 29: staff at Bluewater Detention Centre use language unsuitable for a courtroom, also while audible over the Video Remand system; they are likewise reprimanded -- they're not hired for their soft touch.